European. Contrarian liberal. Insufferable green. History graduate. I never downvote opinions and I do not engage with people who downvote mine. Comments with vulgarity, or snark, or other low-effort content, will also be (politely) ignored.

  • 1 Post
  • 406 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 16th, 2023

help-circle



  • Everyone who cares about privacy needs to have a response to this fallacy practiced and ready to go. The aim should be to convince skeptics that they too already have “things to hide”, or at least that they might show a bit of solidarity with the good guys who do.

    Rhetorical questions can that be effective:

    • Money: How much did you make last month? Oh! That’s private, right.
    • Health: Would you be happy if your medical insurer could somehow get access to your browsing history? Hmm?
    • Politics: So you really are an open book with nothing to hide! Fine. What about whistleblowers, investigative journalists, dissidents, etc? If we’re all shouting “I have nothing to hide - be my guest, spy on me!”, how effective do you think they’re going to be at holding the powerful to account - on our behalf?

    The last argument is the really powerful one, but unfortunately it’s pretty hard to pull off.





  • JubilantJaguar@lemmy.worldtoAsk Lemmy@lemmy.world*Permanently Deleted*
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    9 days ago

    This particular alternative history is uninteresting because its premises mean you have to invent a whole parallel universe. In plain English: it could not have happened and would not have happened, for essentially economic reasons.

    The interesting alternative histories are ones that turn on a single fortuitous event.

    PS: I am saying that OP’s question is boring because it is unanswerable. It just invites a hundred other questions. If you want to ask THOSE questions, then ask them.



  • The downvote button. It’s a hobby horse of mine. Slashdot got it right: if you’re going to tell someone to shut up, there should be a small price to pay.

    PS: to the inevitable downvoters. Let’s be clear that you are not just saying “I disagree”. You are helping to hide my comment; you’re literally telling me to shut up. Would you do that in person, without so much as lifting a finger to justify yourself ? Of course you wouldn’t. In person you would have manners. This is the problem I have with the downvote button. It incites people to behave like uncivilized infants.


  • Agreed on all counts.

    The real mystery to me is what value the echo-chamber residents get out of it. Why would someone join a group of people they already agree with, just to be told that their opinions are correct, and to shout down any interloper who contradict them? How is that not a boring waste of time? Is it that most people are insecure in their views and need validation, perhaps? It’s a phenomenon I still don’t understand.



  • For what it’s worth, I am one of those letters and it is somewhat irrelevant to my identity. My identity is the following: human being.

    I consider the identity obsession of Gen Z to be mostly narcissistic self-regard. It reflects our society’s rampant individualism, where kids have become a lifestyle choice and pampered like fragile consumer objects. I don’t have any answers about how to fix any of this. Indeed I’m something of an individualist myself.

    Be nice to people, but don’t feel the need to indulge their whims if it feels unreasonable.




  • Sounds awful. Your situation is extreme (ah rural America!) but I won’t deny there’s something freeing about cars. These days I hate cars with a passion, and I’ve always lived in big European cities where they’re completely unnecessary, but even I had a car when I was 20, and I loved it. But then a couple of years later I got rid of it, and that also felt like freedom and I loved that too… Anyway, just an anecdote. As for your situation, good luck, you’ll find a way out of there.

    PS off-topic: I’ve always found “good luck” to be a bit lacking for these contexts, in French there’s the much better “bon courage”, sadly untranslatable but much more appropriate in your case.